NBC Sports

More news in NBCSports

Who's reputation is hurt more by Magic's book?

Background reading

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Results
Total of 954 votes

39.8%
Magic Johnson
380 votes
60.2%
Isiah Thomas
574 votes
advertisement

Newsvine Discussion with 13 comments - Click here to jump to the comment form.

{"commentId":10236677,"authorDomain":"Nawlins"}

I think this is a sad way for friends to behave. Neither one has anything to gain. Magic Johnson's sexual exploits are well-documented and Isiah is who he is! Two black men discussing B/S in a book; What's the point?

I give Isiah credit....at least he's keeping real! I'm not sure what hell Majic was thinking....I could care less about Bird's motives because he fired Isiah the first chance he got when he got to Indiana! Enuf said!

{"commentId":10236677,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"Nawlins"}
    Reply#1 - Thu Oct 22, 2009 8:11 PM EDT
    {"commentId":10236766,"authorDomain":"gene504"}

    So it turns out that Magic is the big grinning snake!

    {"commentId":10236766,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"gene504"}
      Reply#2 - Thu Oct 22, 2009 8:17 PM EDT
      {"commentId":10236966,"authorDomain":"mach4"}

      The Magic turns out to be a doggone back stabber. Stabs him in the back and blames Isiah for not looking. A successful business man he has become, we now understand his MOD!

      {"commentId":10236966,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"mach4"}
        Reply#3 - Thu Oct 22, 2009 8:30 PM EDT
        {"commentId":10241658,"authorDomain":"markosb"}

        You don't become one of the best basketball players ever by being a nice guy, everyone has snakes in there closets. I was a big Detroit fan in the 80's. There both competitors and did what ever it took to win and apparently that is still true.

        {"commentId":10241658,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"markosb"}
          #3.1 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 4:25 AM EDT
          Reply
          {"commentId":10240205,"authorDomain":"beer-mug"}

          Where there is smoke, there is usually fire. Without knowing the facts, I'd trust Magic over Isiah anyday especially in view of the carnage that Thomas seems to leave in his wake wherever he goes.

          {"commentId":10240205,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"beer-mug"}
            Reply#4 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 12:10 AM EDT
            {"commentId":10240597,"authorDomain":"nocall4it"}

            Damn, all those years when I disliked Magic I couldn't quite put a finger on it now, I know, the brother is a piece of @!$%#. Who the hell is magic anyway, a simple basketball player, his uncle tom business exploits are just that, maybe that's how he got AIDS, sucking dick. What an @!$%#.

            {"commentId":10240597,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"nocall4it"}
              Reply#5 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 12:50 AM EDT
              Reply
              {"commentId":10241849,"authorDomain":"rightjustone"}

              My problem with this latest revelation about Magic playing a role in keeping Isiah off the "Dream Team" is this.....For so long it was asserted that Jordan was the main instigator in boycotting Isiah off the team. Basically Jordan took the fall. If Magic had anywhere near an influence in that decision, why wasn't he man enough to reveal his role in the matter. He (Magic) allowed Jordan to be the fall guy, while maintaining his "Hollywood smiling image." Magic should have been man enough to acknowledge his culpablity long ago, not just now when it is convenient to promote a book. I'd be interested to hear Charles Barkley's take on this, you KNOW he will speak his mind.

              {"commentId":10241849,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"rightjustone"}
                Reply#6 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 5:43 AM EDT
                {"commentId":10244711,"authorDomain":"TANKMTS"}

                I'm very disappointed in Magic Johnson. The bottom line is that his sexual exploits were his own and no one else's! No matter what or who was saying anything, the bottom line is that he brought his consequences on himself! Now, to put in a book all of this negative stuff about someone you considered to be a very close friend is very demeaning to your own character! I'm not saying Isiah is a saint, but, at least he has kept the no so good stuff personal. Magic will probably make a lot of money on the book, but, is it truly worth it when you trash not only someone else's character, but, your own? That's something he'll have to decide (which it looks like he already has) and live with it.

                {"commentId":10244711,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"TANKMTS"}
                  Reply#7 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 10:20 AM EDT
                  {"commentId":10248979,"authorDomain":"PaulinKY"}

                  I personally would have a hard time believing Mr. Thomas if he told me the sun rose in the East.

                  {"commentId":10248979,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"PaulinKY"}
                    Reply#8 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 1:43 PM EDT
                    {"commentId":10250625,"authorDomain":"keith-10"}

                    Magic was a GREAT basketball player and as a Laker's Fan one of my all time favorites. That being said he should simply keep his mouth shut. It hurts Thomas and himself. Stupid, Stupid, Stupid. But then no one ever said that to be a great Basketball player you needed any common sense.

                    {"commentId":10250625,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"keith-10"}
                      Reply#9 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 3:00 PM EDT
                      {"commentId":10252296,"authorDomain":"BKJACKSON"}

                      I had already lost respect for Magic when he decided to ride with Hilary over Obama. I found myself in the store one day looking for suits and came across Magic's designer line (inside lining purple and gold) and thought to myself "not in this lifetime", what a sucker Majic is and called himself a freind. There a song out was that with a little like this "smile in your face all the time want to take your place back stabbers". Why bring up some bull to sell books, Majic's next book tilte should be "I'm a all day sucker and a part time fool"

                      {"commentId":10252296,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"BKJACKSON"}
                        Reply#10 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 4:17 PM EDT
                        {"commentId":10252568,"authorDomain":"BKJACKSON"}

                        I lost respect for Majic when he decided to ride with Hilary over Obama. I was in the store one day looking for dress suits, came across Majic's designer line (inside purple and gold), thought to myself not in this lifetime. Majic called himself a friend to Isiah while all the time he was stabbing him in the back and smiling in his face. There was a song out that describes Majic to the tee "They smile in your face all the time want to take your place, the back stabbers". After all this time Majic shows his true color "yellow" what a coward. Majic's next book title should be "ALL DAY SUCKER AND A PART TIME FOOL".

                        {"commentId":10252568,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"BKJACKSON"}
                          Reply#11 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 4:30 PM EDT
                          {"commentId":10259115,"authorDomain":"mrpictureman"}

                          Okay I will say it shouldn't Magic have died of HIV by now?

                          {"commentId":10259115,"threadId":"707648","contentId":"3413693","authorDomain":"mrpictureman"}
                            Reply#12 - Sat Oct 24, 2009 1:05 AM EDT
                            {"canLink":false,"threadId":"707648","isPrivate":false}
                            Leave a Comment:
                            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.