Who's the NFL's best QB?

Mon Feb 8, 2010 12:02 AM EST

Results with 70 short comments
Total of 9,518 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

Peyton Manning	32.4% (3,080 votes)
Drew Brees	29.7% (2,830 votes)
Tom Brady	16.7% (1,594 votes)
Brett Favre	9.2% (876 votes)
Ben Roethlisberger	4.2% (403 votes)
Aaron Rodgers	2.4% (229 votes)
Other	2.1% (200 votes)
Philip Rivers	1.4% (132 votes)
Tony Romo	1.2% (110 votes)
Donovan McNabb	0.7% (64 votes)

Display Comments:

Other

John Elway - a warrior and MORE 4th Quarter comebacks than anyone. P.S. - I am a K.C. Chiefs fan.

- lancemh

- 12:22 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Drew Brees

Not only because he won the Super Bowl, but because he is one of the classiest professional athletes in the US today.

- hoverguy

- 12:40 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Drew Brees

Drew Dat! Calm, precise, a true leader on and off the field. He lead his team to BELIEVE beat three of the best quarterbacks of all tim

- saintfanforever

- 12:58 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Drew Brees

No question. And unlike everyone, It's not just about him.

- WhoDatHooligan

- 1:28 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Drew Brees

Today it was Drew Brees. Next year? Who knows. However, Brees will be there again in the top of list of all major categories if healthy.

- Peter-585289

- 1:29 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Drew Brees

As of today, it's a no-brainer! Drew Brees out played Mr. Perfect Manning by a mile.

- George-421202

- 1:45 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Drew Brees

Guts and heart made the difference tonight. Breeze combines the best of Manning and Favre.

- Jones57

- 2:01 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Peyton Manning

Peyton he has been the most consistient over time.
Frew and others are good but too a QB need a good team in front of him.
-ravens fan

1 vote

- albruno

- 4:23 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Peyton Manning

Manning is still the best, but Brees and Brady are right there and all three are winners....

- bobthai

- 4:31 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Peyton Manning

No other quarterback reads defenses better than Manning regardless this loss in the Superbowl.

#10

- Pete Pedro

- 5:04 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Drew Brees

Brees has the similar skills as Manning and Brady, but he has something that most don't... Magic.

#11

- Vanston

- 5:48 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Tom Brady

count the rings

#12

- benrod1

- 5:54 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Other

Terry Bradshaw

#13

- Shogun1615779

- 6:47 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Peyton Manning

Congrats to Drew Brees and the Saints. But ONE game does not make you the best---look at your total career.

1 vote

#14

- Carolyn-1113664

- 7:09 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Brett Favre

Romo shouldn't be on this list at all, and Brady is a total has-been....

#15

- Steve-726645

- 7:35 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Drew Brees

to the victors go the spoils.....congratulations Saints!! Drew Brees had an unbelievable season and deserves all the credit he will receiv

#16

- pissed off and not going to take it anymore

- 7:55 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Tom Brady

What really counts: 4 Superbowl appearances, 3 Championship rings

#17

- happy on sanibel

- 8:24 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Drew Brees

Yesterday and today there was/is no doubt, Drew Brees

#18

- sasch

- 8:26 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Drew Brees

Which team won the Superbowl. The one with Drew Bree's running the offense. Enough said.

#19

- sftwrjunky

- 8:51 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Other

Joe Montana, who else!

#20

- Marj-1120331

- 9:13 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Other

Professional sports is a game of short attention spans . . . one season you're a hit, the next you're not. The possibilities are endless.

#21

- wavychips

- 9:19 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Tom Brady

Nobody has done more with less and won superbowls. David Patten? David Givens? 2 mins to go & need to score? TB is the man!

#22

- Chris-1615896

- 9:20 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Drew Brees

It's all about heart! He is a great football player but also a good person.

#23

- Bob Martell

- 9:20 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Peyton Manning

Brees is right up there with Manning, and I love the Saints, but Manning is still the best all around QB. It's just undeniable.

1 vote

#24

- E. Hun

- 9:23 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Other

Of this group you have to say Brady. No one in this group has done what Brady has done and I am a Romo fan.

#25

- Dan T-880865

- 9:25 am EST on Mon Feb 8, 2010

Jump to short comment page: 1 2 3

Explore related topics: nfl

Jump to discussion page: 1 2

hoverguy

Drew Brees - Not only for turning 42 years of Aints into Saints, but because he is one of the classiest athletes in professioanl sports today.

#1 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 12:44 AM EST

Amare1623

This is BS. Just cos Mannings D couldnt do their job, you people suddenly jump ship to Brady?!?! Sheesh people Cmon man..

You can't tell me, that if your life was on the line, you wouldnt want P Manning playing for ya.

1 vote

#2 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 12:47 AM EST

Chris-1615896

I wouldn't.

#2.1 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 9:24 AM EST

hoverguy

New

#3 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 12:49 AM EST

hoverguy

New Orleans and Louisiana thank you for your undying support for the city and your fans!

#4 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 12:53 AM EST

Dolly Falcone

Awesome Superbowl but the Saints deserve all the glory because they had the heart to win this game. Congratulations

1 vote

#5 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 8:23 AM EST

sasch

Yesterday and today there was/is no doubt, Drew Bres.........

#6 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 8:31 AM EST

Jmat40

Big Ben has more rings than three of the four QB's ranked ahead of him.

For some reason the media and fans in general refuse to give him his proper due as the best big game QB in football.

Drew Brees is great but he needs to win multiple Championships or at least multiple division titles before being anointed the newest greatest QB of all time.

1 vote

#7 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 8:51 AM EST

Languishing in Jersey

Maybe if he led his team to more big games, and they won, people would "recognize" his greatness. Respect is earned on the field, and greatness judged by the results.

#7.1 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 11:08 AM EST

sftwrjunky

San Diegos biggest mistake was letting Drew Bree's go. The rest is history. Congratulations to The Saints on a great upset victory.

#8 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 8:53 AM EST

libertybells

Drew has his moment of recognition. Peyton still outranks Drew and everyone knows this.

#9 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 9:27 AM EST

9erFan

Joe Montana, of course!

#10 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 9:52 AM EST

Languishing in Jersey

Maybe you hadn't noticed: Montana isn't in the NFL anymore.

#10.1 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 11:02 AM EST

Materialman80

Today it's Drew Brees, no question! Bravo Saints! What a season!

#11 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 9:58 AM EST

MJM-796261

Tom Brady - 4 Super Bowl Appearances - 3 Rings. Each season, the Patriots traded away or lost key players to other teams - especially wide receivers and tight ends and running backs, and each year, Brady finds a way to win. Now that Brady's back from the injury and can still play - maybe they can add a few key players and see what he can do again.

#12 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 11:01 AM EST

Big Black Dog

who dat?

#13 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 11:05 AM EST

Big Black Dog

Who dat second who dat?

#14 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 11:06 AM EST

yankeeyankee

Wasn't that said by Rochester, the valet on the old Jack Benny show; or from Amos & Andy? We used it at home growing up when somebody suddenly was heard but not seen.

#14.1 - Wed Feb 10, 2010 9:29 AM EST

DM DelSur

Brees at this moment. All others are good, capable quarterbacks, and could be the best at this moment next year. Aaron Rogers may be the one with the most potential to contend for the "next best at this moment in time". As we know, winning at this level with the most talented of the talented can be fickle, and often can be a game of "breaks", and this Super Bowl no exception. The interception iced it, and without it it could have gone into overtime with the luck of the winning coin toss the determinent of the ultimate outcome. A great game by the Saints, and even though Colts had lost momentum, a tie was in the making until the interception.

#15 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 11:34 AM EST

Free Mason-1490678Deleted

JCook-1049822

Right, I cannot deny they have not, just like you cannot deny Jeter, Matsui, and A-Rod (as a Yankee) have not.

1 vote

#17 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 12:17 PM EST

EL Chupab

3 supper-bowls

#18 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 12:47 PM EST

Coach Du Fer

Drew Brees was let down, time and again, by both the Organization and team mebers of the Chargers, before the former threw him away like so much trash. (And they are still suffering from the same old mediocrity in San Diego.)

#19 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 2:18 PM EST

JIM -657002

Aaron Rodgers will be the best QB in the very near future

#20 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 3:19 PM EST

Free Mason-1490678Deleted

USAEXEC

another PURDUE QB wins the Super Bowl!!!!!

#21 - Mon Feb 8, 2010 5:40 PM EST

Jump to discussion page: 1 2

Results with 70 short comments Total of 9,518 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

Discuss this post

Results with 70 short comments
Total of 9,518 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments