Is Jim Caldwell's first season a failure if the Colts don't win the Super Bowl?

Wed Feb 3, 2010 11:55 AM EST

Live Poll

Is Jim Caldwell's first season a failure if the Colts don't win the Super Bowl?

View Results
  • 81336
    Yes, Indy has to win it all
    33%
  • 81337
    No, just reaching the Super Bowl is a success
    67%

VoteTotal Votes: 584

Results with 4 short comments
Total of 584 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

33%
Yes, Indy has to win it all
193 votes
67%
No, just reaching the Super Bowl is a success
391 votes
Display Comments:
No, just reaching the Super Bowl is a success

The offense may be all Manning, but give Caldwell some credit on the Defense

    #1
     - reader117
     - 12:28 pm EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
    Yes, Indy has to win it all

    Yes.

      #2
       - SAGGG
       - 4:43 pm EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
      No, just reaching the Super Bowl is a success

      The "Aint's" don't even have a prayer! GO COLTS!

        #3
         - Jack Gildea
         - 5:35 pm EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
        No, just reaching the Super Bowl is a success

        Waht a dumb story!! The Colts will win; or they wont win!! The Saints will win, or they wont! NO season is a failure reaching this game!

          #4
           - Tom in NH-294381
           - 7:45 pm EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
          — Filed under: ,

          Back To Top | Front Page

          Discuss this post

          Comment author avatarDave Stout

          Unbelievable. Pundits are not athletes and don't understand sports any more than a 6th grader. If you look back at the Super Bowls the best QB in the NFL wasn't on the winning team more than 80% of the time. Football is a strange and fascinating combination of will, discipline, luck and brains. Heck the best team only wins about 50% of time. Give Caldwell a break.

            Reply#1 - Wed Feb 3, 2010 8:49 PM EST
            footballyguy84Deleted
            Author avatarLeave a Comment:
            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
            Newsvine Privacy Statement
            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
            Advertise | AdChoices
            Get Updates
            NBCSports on Newsvine

            This is a gathering of links, stories and votes that the editors at NBCSports.com like. Hopefully, Newsvine also like 'em.

            NBCSports.com
            3622,5
            Archives
            By Tag:
            – Show More
            Advertise | AdChoices