Is the Heisman Trophy still a meaningful award?

Tue Dec 1, 2009 1:20 PM EST

Results with 4 short comments
Total of 367 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

31.9%

Yes, it's still a great honor

117 votes

68.1%

No, it doesn't identify the best player in college football and no one remembers who wins anyway

250 votes

Display Comments:

Yes, it's still a great honor

Yes, it's still a great honor, but your criticisms are valid. But, as with many things in college football, the system...

- 10:37 pm EST on Tue Dec 1, 2009

No, it doesn't identify the best player in college football and no one remembers who wins anyway

It who ever they "NCAA" want to win. Last year Bradford was not the best QB in his conference but still took home the trophy.

- 11:30 am EST on Wed Dec 2, 2009

Yes, it's still a great honor

Just because some people pick individuals based upon their own criteria doesn't mean that the Heisman isn't still prestigous.

- 1:42 pm EST on Wed Dec 2, 2009

No, it doesn't identify the best player in college football and no one remembers who wins anyway

How long has it been since a Heisman winner really did well in the NFL?

- 3:50 pm EST on Sat Dec 5, 2009

Are we rewarding the system or the player in the system?

#1 - Wed Dec 2, 2009 11:32 AM EST